
Nick Swisher, we hardly knew ye.
The Dirty Thirty era has ended after one up and down season. It started bad, got better, and ended worse than it began. It wasn't entirely his fault, but he nonetheless failed in his first and only season on the South Side.
I was excited last year when the Sox brought him in. While he was in Oakland, I was witness to many a game when Swisher beat the Sox with clutch hitting and an annoying, gamer attitude. So when they brought him in, I was on board.
The only thing he really brought was that annoying attitude. He did provide some solid power numbers, and was the most patient hitter the Sox had. But his batting average was atrocious. And his defense in centerfield was even worse.
Things got better when PK went to the DL for awhile. Playing in his natural 1st base job, Swish improved his hitting, and his defense was solid. But when PK came back, Swish went back to the outfield, where his Sox career died. He was shuffled in and out of the lineup, playing multiple positions, and just never seemed to get comfortable. By the time September rolled around, he was a bench player and barely played in the playoffs.
Maybe he tried too hard. Maybe he wanted to make such a good impression that he pressed too much. And maybe as the season went on, he couldn't get the slump out of his head. Who knows. But the bottom line was he had no place on the '09 Sox. 1st base is PK's. Thome is the DH. Dye (for now) and CQ are the corner outfielders. And he wasn't going back to CF.
Truth be told, I would rather they kept Swish and traded PK. Swish is younger, cheaper, and a better defensive 1st baseman. But PK has an almost full no-trade clause. So that wasn't happening.
I also felt Swish tried too hard to promote his blue-collar, grinder attitude. He tried to seem like the grinder type, the one that plays hard and gets clutch hits and does the little things to win games. He didn't really do much of any. So in the end, he just seemed like another vaguely douchey guy. And really, a team can't have a lot of those guys on it's roster. AJ has that distinction locked down anyway.
But at the same time, I feel the need to rip on Kenny a little bit here. Wilson freaking Betemit? Seriously??? That's the best you can do??? He traded an everyday player for a middling utility infielder. I don't get it. I know a couple young pitchers were also received, but as the saying goes, prospects are always suspects until they prove otherwise.
The offseason is still young. I'm hoping Kenny does better than this...